Ayn Rand/Objectivism Sightings
Free Radical Updates
Local Club Meeting Plans
News & Interesting Links
Foundations of Human Sociality by Joseph Henrich|
|Game theory explorations with 15 "primitive" societies reveals what makes us WEIRD people special. What is it to be "Western Educated Industrialized Rational Democratic"? |
The Foundations of Human Sociality: Economic Experiments and Ethnographic Evidence from Fifteen Small-Scale Societies edited by Joseph Henrich, Robert Boyd, et al., Oxford University Press, 2004.
Anthropologists from UCLA and other schools set out to apply Game Theory exercises in fifteen so-called “primitive” (small-scale) societies. Contrary to the "noble savage" mythology, first of all, these societies are different from each other. Hunter-gatherers in one place do not share the values of similar folk in another place: culture matters. Different people have different cultures. That said, all of them are different from us. We, the Western Educated Industrialized Rational Democratic ("WEIRD") people stand out. For one thing, we are anonymously generous: we all throw a buck in the Red Kettle at Christmas time, even though we gain no social status from doing that. Some hunter-gatherers are far more generous than we are - but only because it is socially demanded of them for status. And they resent it. Other hunter-gatherers sneak their kills in after dark, to avoid sharing.
Contrary to the "selfishness axiom" some people (the Au and related Gnau of New Guinea) refused large gifts because they brought a concomitantly large demand of reciprocity. (Just to note, for other research, I met the same attitude among herders in Morocco.)
Of all the data, perhaps the most subtle point expresses the root of self-ish behavior and rational self interest:
The take-away point is that those peoples who have some exposure to market exchange and market integration more closely scored like American undergraduates. They had internalized a sense of "fairness." Interestingly, all of the university volunteers from across the nation (and, the editors alluded, also across the Atlantic) scored narrowly together. Moreover, they did so in a curiously bi-modal distribution of egoism and altruism.
This book provides a rich, dense, timely, and cogent exploration into the significant ways that we WEIRD people stand alone in the world.